Home | Contact Us | Archive | Online Books | Subscribe    

Jana Sangh Today | A Monthly Magazine

Editorial Ideological Historical Media Gallery

Write to us | Email this Story


Record
Tit For Tat
Oct 2006

 

From Rafiq Zakaria

From Rafiq Zakaria's book

The (U.K. Cabinet) Mission asked Jinnah: �Do you realise that the Pakistan you are demanding will leave substantial Hindus under Muslim domination?�

Jinnah replied: �That will be so; but I will leave many more Muslims under Hindu domination in Hindustan.�

Surprised at this reply the Mission said: �How does it then resolve Hindu�Muslim discord? It will only perpetuate the hostilities.�

Jinnah persisted: �I will free at least two�third Muslims from Hindu domination.�

The Mission told him: �And you will put more than that number of Hindus under Muslim domination. That is no solution.�

Jinnah was adamant. He asserted: �That is the only solution if you don't want civil war.�

The Mission was nonplussed at his stand and asked: �But should you adopt such a callous attitude towards the minorities in the two states, they will be in worse condition than the Muslims in united India � also the Muslims in divided India will be the worst sufferers.�

Jinnah replied: �Their best protection will be the establishment of two strong states, neither of which will dare misbehave towards each other's minorities.�

The Mission enquired: �you mean to say that these minorities will be hostages.�

Jinnah said: �Exactly. If one state mistreats its minorities, the other state will retaliate against its minorities. It will be tit for tat.�

The Mission was aghast at this reply and remarked: �That is a horrible concept which did not work even in medieval times.�

March 2013

Editorial
Unfinished Agenda of the Partition in 1947

Historical
Exchange Of Populations

Media Gallery
"People Denigrating Tipu Varsity For Partisan Ends"

Media Gallery
Communal Fuse

Controversy
Syed Shahabuddin

Online Books
Prafull Goradia Website
GreenMindz
 


Write


Read

© janasangh.com 2013 Designed & Hosted by GreenMindz